News reports often say that "the market" rose or fell, and they usually mean a market index. An index sounds like a thing, but it is closer to a gauge on a control panel: a single needle driven by many inputs through a fixed circuit. This article describes the circuit. All companies and numbers in it are invented for illustration.
An index is a rulebook plus a calculator
In one line: the methodology document defines every input and every step.
Every index is run by an index provider that publishes a methodology: the rules that say which securities are included, how much each one counts and how the result is calculated and maintained. The provider then calculates the index level, often many times a day, from current prices. Nothing is bought or held to produce the number. A fund that wants to follow an index has to buy the securities itself.
Choosing the constituents
In one line: eligibility rules filter the whole market down to a list.
The securities in an index are its constituents. Methodologies typically filter them with rules such as:
- where the security is listed and where the company is based;
- a minimum size, usually measured by market value;
- a minimum free float, meaning the share of stock actually available to outside investors rather than held by founders or governments;
- a minimum level of daily activity, so that the price is formed by regular buying and selling;
- sector or theme rules for narrower indexes.
The list is reviewed on a schedule, often quarterly, when some companies enter and others leave.
Weighting: how much each constituent counts
In one line: the weighting method decides how far each company moves the needle.
Once the list exists, the methodology decides each constituent's influence. Three methods are common:
- Market-value weighting
- Each company counts in proportion to its share price times the number of shares counted, often adjusted for free float. Larger companies move the index more. Most broad indexes use this method.
- Price weighting
- Each company counts in proportion to its share price alone, so a company with a high price per share has more influence regardless of its size.
- Equal weighting
- Each company counts the same, and the weights are reset to equal at every review.
The table shows how the first and third methods treat the same three invented companies.
| Company | Share price | Shares counted | Market value | Weight by market value | Weight if equal |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Company A | $50 | 2,000,000 | $100 million | 50% | 33.3% |
| Company B | $20 | 3,000,000 | $60 million | 30% | 33.3% |
| Company C | $10 | 4,000,000 | $40 million | 20% | 33.3% |
Under market-value weighting, a 10% move in Company A's share price moves the index about twice as much as the same move in Company C. Under equal weighting, the two moves would count the same.
From weights to one number: the divisor
In one line: total market value divided by a divisor gives the level.
For a market-value index, the calculation adds up the counted market value of every constituent, then divides by a number called the divisor. When the index is launched, the divisor is chosen so that the level starts at a round base value, such as 100 or 1,000. In our example, total market value is $200 million; a divisor of 200,000 would give a starting level of 1,000.
The divisor's real job comes later. When a company issues new shares, buys back shares or is replaced in the index, the total market value changes for reasons that have nothing to do with price movements. The provider adjusts the divisor at that moment so that the level does not jump. As a result, changes in the level reflect changes in prices, not changes in the list.
Price and total return versions
In one line: one index can be published with and without dividends.
A price index counts only changes in share prices. A total return version of the same index assumes that dividends paid by constituents are reinvested, so it adds them back into the calculation. Over long periods, the two versions can drift far apart, which is why it matters which one a document refers to. Providers may also publish versions in different currencies.
What an index level does not tell you
In one line: a level summarizes a list; it does not describe any one holding or any fund.
An index level says nothing about how any single constituent behaved. It does not include the costs that a fund following it would pay, so a fund's result usually differs from the index's. It reflects the provider's choices about eligibility and weighting, and a different rulebook applied to the same market can produce a different picture. Market-value indexes can also become concentrated when a few large companies grow to dominate the total.
Read as a gauge, an index is useful because its circuit is published. Before comparing two indexes, or a fund with an index, the first step is to read both rulebooks.
Educational content, not advice
This article explains a general mechanism. It is not a recommendation to buy, sell or hold any security, and it does not take your personal circumstances into account. All investments carry risk, including the possible loss of capital.